Joan has the voice of an angel, but wtf is this? The Beatles version is perfection. This adds nothing. Totally redundant. A shame. There are Beatles songs worth re-doing, as Elton proved.
This rendition of Eleanor Rigby is absolutely the most beautiful and haunting. As someone else said, "Joan you have the voice of an angel", and to this commenter, you bring a poignancy to this song that no one else has ever gotten close to. I thank the Beatles for writing Eleanor Rigby.